Between "we'd like to make you an offer" and "I accept" sits the only stretch of the entire relationship where the company wants something from you more than you want something from them. They have spent weeks and a good deal of money getting here. Their other finalist has probably taken another job.
It lasts about 72 hours. Most people spend it being grateful.
The order of operations
Do these in sequence and almost nothing can go wrong.
Say thank you and ask for it in writing. Do not accept on the call — not because accepting would be wrong, but because "I'd love to see the full package in writing before I confirm" is a completely normal sentence that buys you two days. Nobody has ever been penalized for it.
Read the whole document, not the base salary line. Bonus structure, equity and vesting, retirement match, health premiums, leave, start date, notice on either side.
Work out one number and one reason. Then send one email. Then stop.
The single most common failure I see is not asking too much — it is negotiating in dribs, raising base on Tuesday, leave on Wednesday, and a start date on Friday. Bundle everything into one message. Recruiters can approve a package. They cannot approve four separate irritations.
When they ask for your number first
Advertisement
At some point someone will ask what you are looking for, usually early enough that you have no idea what the role pays.
Three ways out, in order of how much I like them.
Deflect once: "I'd rather hear the range for the role first — what has the team budgeted?" A surprising number of recruiters will simply tell you, especially anywhere pay transparency rules apply.
If pushed, give a range anchored high, and know you will land near its bottom. Say "based on similar roles, I'd expect something in the $95,000 to $105,000 range" and treat $95,000 as your real floor, not your hope.
Never give your current salary. Several US states prohibit employers from asking, and even where it is legal it is the single piece of information most likely to cap your offer at a percentage above where you already are — which has nothing to do with what the new job is worth.
What to do with the number once you have it
Compare it to the whole package, not to the headline. An offer that is $4,000 lower on base but carries a real retirement match and 10 more days of leave can be worth more in cash and considerably more in life. Putting both versions side by side in the comparison calculator takes five minutes and routinely reverses people's instinct about which offer is bigger.
Then decide the one thing you are asking for. One primary ask, with a fallback you would genuinely accept.
| If base is... | Primary ask | Fallback worth taking |
|---|---|---|
| Slightly low, band has room | +5–12% on base | Half of it, plus a 6-month review |
| At the top of a rigid band | Sign-on bonus | Extra leave, or a guaranteed first bonus |
| Fine, but the job is bigger than advertised | Title, then band | A documented scope review at 6 months |
| Right, but the start date is painful | A later start date | Remote days during the transition |
| Below market by a wide margin | Show the data, ask for the band | Walk, politely — this rarely improves later |
The fourth row gets dismissed as trivial and should not be. Three extra weeks before you start, after a hard job search, is worth more to most people than $1,500 of taxed salary.
Writing the actual message
Short. One number. One reason. A sentence that lets them close.
The reason has to be external to you — what the role covers, what comparable roles pay (BLS publishes wage estimates by occupation and metro area through its Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program), or a competing offer that genuinely exists. "I need more because of my mortgage" gives the recruiter nothing they can take to a compensation committee. "This role includes the forecasting work that sat with a senior analyst at my last company, and comparable positions in this metro are in the mid-90s" gives them a sentence they can repeat.
The counter offer email generator does the percentage math first and keeps the draft to that length, which matters because the instinct under pressure is to over-explain. If your negotiation is with a hiring manager rather than a recruiter, and the tone needs to be warmer and less transactional, the AI Email Writer handles that register better.
What happens after you send it
Usually one of three things. They meet it, they meet part of it, or they say the band is fixed.
Meet it or part of it: accept, warmly and quickly. Say thank you, confirm the number, and ask for the updated letter. Do not go back for more. I have watched exactly one person try a second counter after the company moved, and the offer survived — but the hiring manager brought it up eight months later, which tells you how these things are remembered.
Band is fixed: ask for the things around the band, then decide. And ask one specific question before you sign — when is the next compensation review, and is there anything preventing an adjustment before then? Get the answer in the email chain rather than on a call.
Silence for more than three working days: send one short nudge, then hold your nerve. Nobody has ever been talked out of hiring someone by a polite follow-up.
Use the window while it is open
Ask for the letter, read all of it, pick one number and one reason, send one email inside 48 hours. That is the whole method and it beats improvising every time.
Put your offer, your target and your reason into our free Counter Offer Email Generator to get a short, specific draft with the percentage already calculated.
FAQ
How much can I realistically negotiate after an offer?
For most professional roles, somewhere between 5 and 12 percent on base is an ordinary outcome when the band has room. Larger moves happen, but they usually need something external behind them — a competing written offer, or clear evidence that the role's scope changed during interviews. If you are told the number is at the ceiling of a published band, that is often true.
Is it worth negotiating a first job out of university?
Yes, with smaller expectations. Graduate programs and structured entry-level schemes frequently do have fixed pay, and pushing hard on base will not work. Start date, location, team assignment, relocation support and sign-on bonuses are much more likely to move, and asking politely once costs you nothing.
Should I mention another offer if I have one?
If it is real and in writing, yes — it is the strongest thing you can bring. Name the company only if you are comfortable doing so, state the number plainly, and say which job you would prefer if the gap closed. What you should not do is invent one. Recruiters in the same city talk more than candidates expect, and a bluff that gets called ends the conversation entirely.